Advice Required.

[truckersau]

Hi all. Ok I've been working on a couple of photos for the last few days, and realy need some advice.
Below are 3 photos.
1/ Original of the one I need advice on.
2/ Where this photo is at, at the moment.
3/ Another one from the same family, that I've just completed
Ok I need to know if it's acceptable to use the little girl from the completed photo, in the one I'm working on.
If not I will try to clean up the original some more.
As always ALL feed back is appreciated.
   1/

   2/

   3/

[Ausimax]

I can't see any reason you can't use her in the other image, same girl, almost the same stance, go for it!

Max

[schen]

The directions of light source were very different in photo #1 and #3.  If the direction they were facing was 12 o'clock, the light source of photo #1 was at 1 o'clock and the photo #3 was 4 o'clock.  The composite #2 looked strange to me.

These two pictures were taken at the same location at the same time of the same two persons.  I would suggest return only the photo #3 and not the badly damaged #3.

[truckersau]

Ok, I managed to pull the little girl out of the damage.
This is the latest copy, thoughts please.
Bye the way, the print size for this is 4x5. And looks a lot better at that size.

[cmpentecost]

I think it's looking really good!  The little girls nose kind of stands out to me as a little too white.  Perhaps a bit of blending here, but otherwise, nice job!

Chris

[schen]

Great job pulling all that out of such a difficult one.

I agree with Christine that the edge of the girl could be blurred a little to blend in with the background.

The lower half of the tie I think was white not damage?

[Tess (Tassie D)]

:up2: You've done a really great job on this Ray. I'd borrow the little girls hair from the other photo to finish it off. That tie is strange but I think schen is right, it is white.

[truckersau]

Thanks guys, I made those little changes.
It realy helps to have other eyes look at it.